Hyperbaric Oxygen Therapy & Autoimmune Disease
Hyperbaric Oxygen has been studied in Autoimmunity
Autoimmunity is an overwhelmingly prominent spectrum of health concerns. Despite, its prevalence effective, safe, durable options still elude us. Hyperbaric oxygen interestingly has a wealth of data supporting its use in autoimmunity. Although Hyperbaric Oxygenation stimulates intracellular reactive oxygen species (ROS) production, as well as leukocytic oxidative action the evidence overwhelmingly supports positive effect in numerous autoimmune diseases.
Looking at underlying mechanisms of Hyperbaric therapy in autoimmunity is the first place to explore:
Firstly, on the topic of ROS, activity of the enzymatic antioxidants superoxide dismutase (SOD), glutathione peroxidase (GPx), and catalase (CAT) is upregulated in response to generation of reactive oxygen species. Data from human MS patients demonstrate that superoxide dismutase and catalase values significantly increase after Hyperbaric Oxygen as a natural mechanism to combat excess ROS with modest changes in GPx (Ansari 1986).
According to Butler (2009) the positive clinical effects that HBOT has in the treatment of chronic inflammation may relate to its supressive effects on secretion of pro-inflammatory cytokines such as IL-1, IL-6, and TNF-α. Hyperbaric Oxygen causes downregulation of cytokines and upregulation of growth factors and levels of prostaglandin E2 and cyclo-oxygenase-2 are markedly reduced (also inflammatory).
In the study of a Rheumatoid Arthritis model exposed to Hyperbaric Pressures, Harnanik (2020) found a significant decrease in the expression of Th17, IL-17a, RF levels, and the clinical scores and the expression of inflammation regulating Treg cells increased significantly.
The in autoimmunity, Hyperbaric Oxygen displays immunosuppressive effects including decreased production CD4 cells (Helper T) and increased percentage of CD8 cells (Al-Waili et al. 2006)
Hyperbaric Oxygen exposures may contribute to the repair of focal areas of damage from autoimmunity via the release of stem cells. One human study found a course of 20 sessions at 2.4 ATA 5 days a week for a month in human patients was found to increase circulating stem cells eightfold (Thom et al. 2006).
Several cases of psoriasis have been reported to be successfully treated by HBO.
HBO has been used as an adjunct to phototherapy in the treatment of 45 patients. The course of the disease was shortened as compared with conventional treatment with an average duration of remission of 18 months.
Butler (2009) showed good results in two patients with the use of multiple sessions of Hyperbaric Oxygen at 2.8 ATA for 60 min.
In the first case, A 40-year-old man with disseminated full body psoriasis (had a history of psoriasis from infancy) and also had psoriatic arthritis since childhood. He was not taking any medications at the time of treatment. He underwent Hyperbaric treatment once a day, 5 days per week for a total of eight sessions, resulting in significant amelioration of symptoms. Most of the psoriatic lesions were cleared, with marked reduction in itching and scaling. Follow up at 18 months revealed that the patient had only mild skin symptoms with degenerative changes of the arthritis.
In the second case, A 55-year-old man was referred for Hyperbaric treatment for management of chronic leg ulcers and bone infection; he also had extensive psoriasis. He underwent Hyperbaric treatment at 2.0 ATA for 90 minutes, once a day, 5 days per week. After six sessions his rednwess, scaling and itching were reduced and after 15 sessions he had improved even more.
The time course of response to treatment imply that both cases benefitted from Hyperbaric Oxygen. The authors suggest that appropriately elevated levels of ROS might prevent and treat psoriasis through enhancing Treg function.
Our Naturopathic Doctors have a lot of experience with Psoriasis; it seems to be a common condition in Edmonton. The Naturopathic approach favors identification of food allergens, modification of gut flora and improving gut integrity. Several investigators have observed marked improvement or complete resolution of skin lesions in patients with psoriasis after they went on allergen reduced diets and our Naturopaths have seen similar results. Essential fatty acids, Vitamin D and Curcumin are also frequent considerations of ours in Psoriasis.
Hyperbaric Oxygen and Autoimmune Disease
Saikovsky et al. (1986) used Hyperbaric treatment of 20 patients with rheumatoid arthritis and recommend it as an appropriate therapy especially if systemic symptoms were present.
Lukich et al. (1991) treated 35 patients with rheumatoid arthritis with Hyperbaric Oxygen. Each patient received 21 sessions of 1.7 ATA for 40 min and good clinical results were obtained.
The authors suggested Hyperbaric treatment "intensified the suppressive function of T lymphocytes and decreased the serum concentration [of] immune complexes."
Rui-Chang (1994) treated 37 patients with rheumatoid arthritis with Hyperbaric Oxygen Therapy and found relief of pain and swelling with improved mobility. Nine patients (24.3 %) recovered completely, 19 (51.4 %) improved markedly, and 6 (16.2 %) showed slight improvement. Only 3 (8.1 %) patients failed to respond.
Naturopathic medicine once again uses foods as the foundation primarily because numerous investigators have reported that food allergy is an etiological or triggering factor in some patients with RA and identification and avoidance of allergenic foods resulted in improvement or complete resolution of symptoms, which our Naturopaths have confirmed in clinical practice.
In one study, twenty-two patients with RA consumed a diet that excluded common allergens. Twenty of which (91%) experienced an improvement in symptoms, and 19 found that ingestion of specific foods repeatedly exacerbated their symptoms.
Borage seed oil is a Naturopathic favorite. Borage seed oil contains a high concentration (23%) of the anti-inflammatory omega-6 fatty acid, gamma-linolenic acid (GLA).
In one study, thirty-seven patients with active RA were randomly assigned to receive (providing 1.4 g/day of Borage or placebo for 24 weeks. Compared with baseline, BSO reduced the number of tender joints by 36%, improved the tender-joint score by 45%, improved the swollen-joint score by 41%, and reduced the swollen-joint count by 28%.
Levels of antibodies IgA and IgM were reduced in the Hyperbaric groups, indicating an immunosuppressive effect of the Hyperbaric Therapy.
Although less commonly seen, our Naturopaths focus on Food Allergy, Gut Flora and boosting acetylcholine levels to maintain muscular strength for Myasthenia Gravis.
Inflammatory Bowel Disease
In a case report by Buchman et al. 2001 Hyperbaric Oxygen has also been used in the treatment of a patient with Ulcerative Colitis, refractory to conventional therapies. The patient was a 24-year-old man diagnosed with pan-colonic ulcerative colitis at the age of 17 years. His current exacerbation was of 22 months' duration, and he had remained corticosteroid-refractory over that time period. He had 4 to 10 bowel movements daily and, occasionally, up to 15 daily, approximately 50% with blood. Hyperbaric Therapy consisted of 30 courses of 100 % oxygen at a pressure of 2.0ATA.
Clinical remission was achieved, and corticosteroids were successfully tapered off. At the conclusion of HBOT, the patient had achieved two normal bowel movements daily.
In case reports by Green et al. 2013 two pediatric patients with exacerbations of Crohn’s disease without improvement despite standard therapy underwent cycles of Hyperbaric Oxygen Therapy.
Following Hyperbaric treatment both patients showed resolution of the inflammatory lesions and improvement in conditions, enabling them to reduce drug therapy.
The authors concluded "this therapy seems to have offered a safe adjunct in the treatment of refractory exacerbations."
The overall response rate in Crohn’s disease patients was 86 % and in Ulcerative Colitis 88 %.
Of the 40 ulcerative colitis patients with endoscopic follow-up reported, the overall response rate to HBO was 100 %. The conclusion was that HBO is a relatively safe and potentially effective treatment option for IBD patients
The following studies reported on a total of 327 Ulcerative Colitis patients and 286 Crohn's disease patients.
The majority of IBD patients had failed 5‐ASA, steroids and immunomodulator therapy prior to initiating HBOT.
Reference: Dulai 2014
Reference: Dulai 2014
Refractory Perineal Crohn’s Disease is an extremely difficult condition to treat medically or surgically. There are anecdotal case reports of patients who respond dramatically to HBO treatment after failure of multiple medical and surgical treatments. HBO, when integrated in a comprehensive management program including debridement and metronidazole therapy, results in a complete and sustained closure of the fistula.
Seven patients with perineal CD were subjected to daily sessions of HBO in a multiplace hyperbaric chamber with good clinical effects (Weisz et al 1997). Each patient received a total of 20 sessions during a time period of 1 month. IL-1, IL-6, and TNF-α measurements were done several times during the initial sessions and after completing therapy.
During the first 7 days of treatment, IL-1, IL-6, and TNF-α levels in supernatants of LPS-stimulated monocytes derived from patients’ peripheral blood were decreased compared to pretreatment levels. Parallel measurements of serum IL-1 levels revealed an initial elevation and thereafter decreased levels, which remained low throughout the first week of HBO treatment. After completion of therapy, cytokine levels increased to pretreatment values.
Dulai, in a review, showed that overall response rate for perineal CD to HBO therapy was 88 % with 18 of 40 patients having complete healing and 17 had partial healing.
Chronic diarrhea, inflammation, tissue damage and subsequent and malabsorption can lead to multiple nutritional deficiencies, including deficiencies of calories, protein, essential fatty acids, and a wide range of vitamins and minerals in both Crohn's and Ulcerative Colitis. Our Naturopathic Doctors have seen impressive results in many of our Edmonton IBD patients with the use of IV Therapy.
Numerous studies have shown that remission of active Crohn’s disease and Ulcerative Colitis can be induced in up to 90% of patients by feeding a hypoallergenic elemental diet. Therefore our Naturopaths usually begin with food allergy or food sensitivity in our Edmonton IBD patients. We've seen impressive results with precise dietary modification in many IBD patients.
In a 2005 study by Holt, five patients with Ulcerative proctitis and five with Crohn's disease were given oral Curcumin. All proctitis patients improved, with reductions in concomitant medications in four, and four of five Crohn's disease patients had lowered disease activity scores and inflammation rates. So Curcumin is an extract our Naturopaths use frequently in the management of Inflammatory Bowel Disease at our Edmonton clinic.
Hyperbaric Oxygen therapy ameliorated symptoms in Experimental Allergic Encephalomyelitis (EAE) the animal model of multiple sclerosis in numerous studies in the 1970s which led to subsequent human studies primarily in the 1980s.
For instance, Pallota et al. (1986) followed 22 RRMS patients over an 8 year period. All MS patients had an initial course of 20 Hyperbaric Oxygen Treatments, and 11 were treated thereafter with two Hyperbaric treatments every 3 weeks. The relapse frequency decreased dramatically in the long term treatment group.
Data from the United Kingdom, looked at 703 patients (predominantly females with Chronic progressive MS) suggested that after twenty treatments, 70 % of patients obtained relief of two or more symptoms. An analysis suggested that one treatment every 2 weeks was required to retard the progression of relapsing/remitting state where as once weekly was even more effective. We find this data encouraging as 1 treatment every 2 weeks seems reasonable for motivated patients to complete over a long term.
Dr. Muradov is well versed in the Naturopathic Management of MS. Our Naturopaths have many Alternative diagnostic and treatment options at our Edmonton office for MS.
Visit our MS Section for a more detailed discussed on MS & Hyperbaric Oxygen Therapy.
Questions about HBOT?
780 757 8378